Eminem’s back, and with him comes the infamous Slim Shady. But is it a glorious return or a retread of past controversies? “The Death of Slim Shady (Coup de Grace)” is a mixed bag, offering glimpses of the old magic alongside moments that feel dated.
Diehard fans will get a kick out of hearing Slim Shady in top form again. Tracks like “Houdini” showcase Eminem’s signature lightning-fast flow, resurrecting the shock factor that made him a star. However, the shock tactics often feel like reheated leftovers – the targets feel obvious, the references stale.
This inconsistency plagues the album. “Renaissance” starts strong with its wordplay and bravado, but then swerves into tired insults. “Habits” tackles addiction with a promising intro, only to devolve into generic Slim Shady territory.
The production choices are equally curious. “Brand New Dance” sounds like a dad trying to recapture his youth on the dance floor, a vibe that clashes with Eminem’s hardened persona.
There are bright spots, though. “Lucifer” throws back to Wu-Tang’s menacing soundscapes, while “Road Rage” delivers intelligent, gleefully offensive raps. “Bad One” benefits from Dr. Dre’s production, creating a cartoonishly dark soundscape.
Ultimately, “The Death of Slim Shady” doesn’t quite land the knockout blow. While Eminem’s rapping prowess remains undeniable, the album lacks the focus and innovation that defined his golden era. Longtime fans might find a nostalgic thrill, but for others, it’s a reminder that Slim Shady’s edgy act may have worn thin in today’s climate.